At Christmastime, a close-knit group of childhood friends returns home after 10 years to take part in the celebration of life of their beloved high-school teacher.

When relationship advice columnist Amalie Hess receives an unsigned love letter in a Christmas card, she returns to her hometown to solve the mystery of who sent it and maybe find true love.

Corey who works in her mom's antique shop, puts on a Christmas pageant in honor of her late father. When a man named Ryder visits her store, she wonders if she should have left town to follow her dream of becoming a theater director.

A high-flying female novelist from New York takes a trip to the small town that inspired her latest best-seller.

Sarah é uma mulher que se vê em uma encruzilhada quando uma mágica de Natal faz seu desejo de achar um homem perfeito ser realizado. Mas quando a mágica dá vida a Cole, o homem que Sarah sempre quis, ela nem repara em quem esteve sempre ao seu lado.